First Cryptocurrency Court Case in Singapore rules Exchange to Pay for a Glitch

crypto-exchange-does-mistake
Image Source: Shutterstock

First Cryptocurrency Court Case in Singapore rules Exchange to Pay for a Glitch

In a landmark case involving ‘reversing traders‘ on Exchanges, a Singapore court has ruled against the practice. Trader, alias B2C2 wins over crypto exchange operator, Quoine after it arbitrarily cancelled seven of the trader’s order.

Moreover, the most interesting part of the case is that both parties in the transactions were just a bunch of algorithms. No fat fingers or human error involved.

10 BTC in Exchange for 1 Ethereum

It happened during the bull market of early 2017. Quoine operates by deriving it’s price from other crypto exchanges. When the incident occurred, a glitch in it’s system disabled access from other exchanges. Following this, B2C2’s trading software initiated the emergency protocol; a fail-safe price of 10 BTC for 1 ETH.

Reportedly, On April 19, 2017, seven trades were carried out between B2C2 and Quoine exchange at the fail-safe price. 3,092 Bitcoins were credited to B2C2 in exchange for about 309 Ethereum debited; 250 times higher than the actual price.

After Quoine cancelled the orders the next day, B2C2 filled for damages. At the time, the value of 3,092 Bitcoins was over $1k, amount to more than $3 million.

An Involuntary Mistake

Four out of five judges presiding over the case at Singapore International Commercial Court sided with the trader. Moreover, they held that even if it was a mistake, the trading program was not acting with a bad will. That is, the programmer or owner, B2C2 did not design the program to take advantage of the mistake.

The events occurred as per contracts laid in agreement of the owners. Hence, even if it looks like Quoine is not entirely in the wrong here, it will have to pay for the mistakes of it’s computer programs.

The courts have ruled in favor of B2C2 on the grounds of breach of contract and trust. It will now decide on the actual amount of damages to be paid.

Su Zhu, the CEO of Three Arrows Capital and with Deribit Exchange tweeted,

Has some implications imo for any other crypto exchanges who may believe they can reverse customer trades if necessary

In a way, exchanges could reimburse through insurance or act in agreement with the users in case of faulty trades. However, reversing a trade is where legal problems comes in. Moreover, it will also set precedence for other incidents involving unethical or accidental trades on exchanges.

Do you think that the judges made the right call? Please share your views with us. 

Summary
First Cryptocurrency Court Case in Singapore rules Exchange to Pay for a Glitch
Article Name
First Cryptocurrency Court Case in Singapore rules Exchange to Pay for a Glitch
Description
In a landmark case involving 'reversing traders' on Exchanges, a Singapore court has ruled against the practice. Trader, alias B2C2 wins over crypto exchange operator, Quoine after it arbitrarily cancelled seven of the trader's order. 
Author
Publisher Name
CoinGape
Publisher Logo
Coingape is committed to following the highest standards of journalism, and therefore, it abides by a strict editorial policy. While CoinGape takes all the measures to ensure that the facts presented in its news articles are accurate.
Disclaimer The views, opinions, positions or strategies expressed by the authors and those providing comments are theirs alone, and do not necessarily reflect the views, opinions, positions or strategies of CoinGape. Do your market research before investing in cryptocurrencies. The author or publication does not hold any responsibility for your personal financial loss.
Author: Nivesh Rustgi

Nivesh from Engineering Background is a full-time Crypto Analyst at Coingape. He is an atheist who believes in love and cultural diversity. He believes that Cryptocurrency is a necessity to deter corruption. He holds small amounts of cryptocurrencies. Faith and fear are two sides of the same coin. Follow him on Twitter at @nivishoes or mail him at nivesh(at)coingape.com

Post your comment...
Nivesh Rustgi 928 Articles

Nivesh from Engineering Background is a full-time Crypto Analyst at Coingape. He is an atheist who believes in love and cultural diversity. He believes that Cryptocurrency is a necessity to deter corruption. He holds small amounts of cryptocurrencies. Faith and fear are two sides of the same coin. Follow him on Twitter at @nivishoes or mail him at nivesh(at)coingape.com

Follow Nivesh @