Regulation News

Coinbase Lawsuit: Court Rules Secondary Sales Of Crypto Not Securities

Amid an ongoing lawsuit, Coinbase attained a major feat as the US Court of Appeals Second Circuit ruled in its favor by confirming that secondary sales of crypto aren't securities.
Published by
Coinbase Lawsuit: Court Rules Secondary Sales Of Crypto Not Securities

Highlights

  • Coinbase has attained a significant milestone amid an ongoing lawsuit.
  • The US Court of Appeals Second Circuit sided with Coinbase.
  • The court confirmed that secondary sales of crypto by Coinbase do not violate the Securities Exchange Act.

In a significant legal development, the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit has issued a comprehensive ruling on a contentious lawsuit involving crypto exchange Coinbase. The plaintiffs in the case are plaintiffs Louis Oberlander, Christopher Underwood, and Henry Rodriguez. The lawsuit centered on allegations of violations of federal and state securities laws concerning the trading of specific cryptocurrencies on Coinbase.

Advertisement

Court Rules In Favor Of Coinbase Amid The Lawsuit

The plaintiffs asserted federal claims under Sections 5, 12(a)(1), and 15 of the Securities Act of 1933, as well as Sections 5, 15(a)(1), 20(a), and 29(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Additionally, they brought forth state law claims under the securities laws of California, Florida, and New Jersey. These claims were filed on behalf of a nationwide class consisting of individuals.

The affected people include those who bought or sold the tokens on Coinbase’s platforms between October 8, 2019, and the filing of the amended complaint on March 11, 2022. The crux of the dispute lay in determining whether the cryptocurrencies traded on Coinbase’s platform constituted securities under federal and state laws. The plaintiffs contended that Coinbase’s actions amounted to offering and selling unregistered securities. Furthermore, they accused it of violating various provisions of securities laws.

In contrast, Coinbase argued that secondary sales of crypto-assets did not qualify as securities transactions. Hence, the exchange disputed the applicability of securities regulations. The Court of Appeals’ ruling addressed multiple aspects of the case. Moreover, the Second Circuit ultimately reversed certain portions of the lower court’s judgment while affirming others.

Notably, the court held that Coinbase could be held liable under Section 12(a)(1) of the Securities Act for the offer and sale of unregistered securities. However, it dismissed the plaintiffs’ claims under the Securities Exchange Act, citing insufficient evidence of transaction-specific contracts required for rescission under Section 29.

Also Read: Breaking: Coinbase Secures Canadian License Amidst US Regulatory Pressure

Advertisement

Plaintiffs And Defendants Perspective

A pivotal consideration in the court’s decision was the interpretation of Coinbase’s user agreements, which underwent revisions over time. The varying language in different versions of the user agreement complicated the determination of title and privity issues crucial to the case. The court emphasized the need for clarity on which version of the user agreement applied to the plaintiffs’ claims. It highlighted discrepancies that hindered a definitive resolution.

From the plaintiffs’ perspective, the ruling represents progress in holding cryptocurrency platforms accountable under securities laws. In addition, they urged for investor protection in the dynamic crypto landscape. Conversely, the Coinbase exchange maintains that the decision affirms its stance that secondary sales of cryptocurrencies do not constitute securities transactions.

In addition, Coinbase emphasized the importance of regulatory certainty for industry innovation. The Court of Appeals’ decision carries significant implications for the regulation of cryptocurrencies and digital assets.

Moreover, the Coinbase CLO Paul Grewal spotlighted the court’s decision as appreciable. He took to X and wrote, “We appreciate the Second Circuit confirming today what is clear under the federal securities law: there’s no private liability for the secondary trading of digital assets on exchanges like Coinbase. Why? Because contracts matter.”

Also Read: Coinbase (COIN) Price Target Raised by Analyst, Here’s Why

Share
Coingape Staff

CoinGape comprises an experienced team of native content writers and editors working round the clock to cover news globally and present news as a fact rather than an opinion. CoinGape writers and reporters contributed to this article.

Published by
Why trust CoinGape: CoinGape has covered the cryptocurrency industry since 2017, aiming to provide informative insights to our readers. Our journalists and analysts bring years of experience in market analysis and blockchain technology to ensure factual accuracy and balanced reporting. By following our Editorial Policy, our writers verify every source, fact-check each story, rely on reputable sources, and attribute quotes and media correctly. We also follow a rigorous Review Methodology when evaluating exchanges and tools. From emerging blockchain projects and coin launches to industry events and technical developments, we cover all facets of the digital asset space with unwavering commitment to timely, relevant information.
Investment disclaimer: The content reflects the author’s personal views and current market conditions. Please conduct your own research before investing in cryptocurrencies, as neither the author nor the publication is responsible for any financial losses.
Ad Disclosure: This site may feature sponsored content and affiliate links. All advertisements are clearly labeled, and ad partners have no influence over our editorial content.

Recent Posts

  • 24/7 Cryptocurrency News

Ethena Labs Secures Fresh Funding From ArkStream Capital, ENA Price Spikes

Ethena Labs has secured fresh funding from ArkStream Capital as it expands its ecosystem in…

September 6, 2025
  • 24/7 Cryptocurrency News

SEC Forms International Task Force to Crack Down on Pump-and-Dump Schemes

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission has launched a task force designed to tackle cross-border…

September 6, 2025
  • 24/7 Cryptocurrency News

Justin Sun Pledges $20M Buy Following WLFI Wallet Freeze

Justin Sun responded to World Liberty Financial freezing his wallet by promising to purchase $20…

September 6, 2025
  • 24/7 Cryptocurrency News

Expert Blames ‘Secret Committee’ for Rejecting MSTR Stock Inclusion to S&P 500

Michael Saylor's Strategy (NASDAQ: MSTR) missed the inclusion in the S&P 500 index on Friday,…

September 6, 2025
  • 24/7 Cryptocurrency News

MARA Bitcoin Treasury Nears $6 Billion, Trails Only Strategy in Public Rankings

MARA announced that it now holds $5.9 billion worth of Bitcoin. This cements its position…

September 6, 2025
  • 24/7 Cryptocurrency News

Senate Banking Committee Releases Updated Draft Crypto Market Structure Bill

The U.S. Senate Banking Committee has released an updated version of the draft Crypto Market…

September 6, 2025