Ripple vs. SEC: New Scheduling Order Issued by Judge Netburn
Highlights
- Magistrate Judge Sarah Netburn has set new deadlines in the Ripple vs. SEC legal case, allowing the SEC until April 29, 2024.
- Following the SEC's submission, Ripple will have three business days to respond as part of the ongoing discovery phase.
- Ripple Labs argues against the SEC's demand for substantial civil penalties, proposing a more reasonable penalty of $10 million.
Magistrate Judge Sarah Netburn has issued a scheduling order in the ongoing legal battle between Ripple Labs and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The order pertains to Ripple’s request to dismiss the SEC’s recent expert submissions, which aim to strengthen the SEC’s case for remedies and a final judgment. Judge Netburn approved an extension for the SEC until April 29, 2024. They must submit their rebuttal to Ripple’s motion. Following this, Ripple will have three business days to respond.
The scheduling update follows Netburn’s recent nomination as District Judge in the Southern District of New York. She continues to preside over the Ripple vs. SEC case, demonstrating a history of fair rulings perceived as favorable by the crypto community.
XRP’s Stance on SEC’s Claims and Penalties
XRP has contested the SEC’s proposed civil penalties in the ongoing litigation. The blockchain payments firm has opposed the SEC’s call for a large civil penalty, suggesting a penalty not exceeding $10 million instead. Ripple argues that the SEC’s claims are overstated and unsupported by sufficient evidence.
Additionally, Ripple has addressed the lack of evidence for future violations or reckless behavior in its institutional XRP sales. They referenced the Govil case in their defense, arguing against the SEC’s demand for disgorgement. XRP claims that the SEC cannot establish financial harm and insists on deducting legitimate business expenses.
Ripple Argument on ODL and Investment Contracts
Bill Morgan, representing Ripple, has consistently argued that Ripple On-Demand Liquidity (ODL) sales are not investment contracts. Over the past three years, he has emphasized that ODL sales function differently from traditional investments. According to Morgan, customers hold XRP for mere seconds to facilitate cross-border payments, not for investment purposes.
Morgan also highlighted that the ODL is not intended to be an investment vehicle. This argument is central to Ripple’s defense against the SEC’s classification of XRP. Ripple maintains that the SEC has not shown a likelihood of future violations or reckless disregard for its XRP sales. They also cite the Govil case to argue against the SEC’s claim for disgorgement, asserting no proof of financial harm exists.
Read Also: Consensys Fights for Ethereum, Sues SEC to Block Regulation
- John Bollinger Sees ‘W’ Bottom Forming in Ethereum and Solana, Not Bitcoin
- Robert Kiyosaki Calls Bitcoin and Ethereum ‘Real Money,’ Urges Investors to Ditch ‘Fake’ Fiat
- ‘Sell Gold, Buy Bitcoin’: Expert Flags Major Market Bottom Signal
- Ripple Makes ‘Unusual’ $500M Transfer Amid $1 Billion XRP Treasury Plans
- ‘I’m Going Bonkers’: Dave Portnoy Says He’ll Buy XRP Again If It Dips Below This Level
- Solana Price Prediction: Analyst Notes Bearish Breakdown Amid Derivatives Slowdown
- Shiba Inu Price Eyes Recovery as Burn Rate Jumps 10,785% – Can SHIB Hit $0.000016?
- Ethereum (ETH) Price Prediction: Analyst Eyes $7,000 by Q4 as Bitmine Accumulates $281M ETH — Will History Repeat Itself?
- HYPE Price Teeters Amid Weak Technicals and Soaring Liquidations
- XRP Price Prediction As Ripple Announces $1B Treasury Plans – Is a Rebound Imminent?
- Bitcoin Price Prediction Amid Gold’s Parabolic Rally to Second-Largest Reserve Asset
Why Trust CoinGape
CoinGape has covered the cryptocurrency industry since 2017, aiming to provide informative insights Read more…to our readers. Our journal analysts bring years of experience in market analysis and blockchain technology to ensure factual accuracy and balanced reporting. By following our Editorial Policy, our writers verify every source, fact-check each story, rely on reputable sources, and attribute quotes and media correctly. We also follow a rigorous Review Methodology when evaluating exchanges and tools. From emerging blockchain projects and coin launches to industry events and technical developments, we cover all facets of the digital asset space with unwavering commitment to timely, relevant information.
