24/7 Cryptocurrency News

US SEC Fines Flyfish Club $750K for NFT Sales Violations

US SEC charges Flyfish Club for unregistered NFT sales, prompting dissent from Commissioners Peirce and Uyeda over securities classification.
US SEC Fines Flyfish Club $750K for NFT Sales Violations

Highlights

  • Flyfish Club faces SEC penalties over unregistered NFT sales, risking $750K in fines.
  • Commissioners Peirce and Uyeda dissent, urging clarity for NFT creators under SEC rules.
  • Congressman William Timmons has introduced a bill, New Frontiers in Technology Act, to protect NFTs from the SEC's crackdown.

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has issued an order against Flyfish Club, LLC, for the unregistered sale of non-fungible tokens (NFTs). The decision has drawn criticism from within the agency, highlighting a growing divide over how NFTs and other digital assets should be regulated under U.S. securities laws.

Advertisement

SEC Takes Action Against Flyfish Club Over NFT Sales

The SEC has charged Flyfish Club, a New York-based company, for raising approximately $14.8 million through selling around 1,600 NFTs between August 2021 and May 2022. These NFTs were marketed as memberships that would grant holders exclusive access to a planned high-end dining club. 

The regulatory agency’s enforcement action asserts that Flyfish’s NFTs qualify as securities under federal law due to their potential for resale at higher values and the possibility of earning passive income through leasing.

Based on these findings, the regulatory agency determined that Flyfish violated Sections 5(a) and 5(c) of the Securities Act of 1933 by failing to register these NFTs as securities. The order mandates that Flyfish cease and desist from future violations, pay $750,000 in civil penalties, and destroy all NFTs in its possession within ten days.

Advertisement

Dissenting Commissioners Criticize the Decision

However, not all within the US SEC agree with the crackdown. Commissioners Hester Peirce and Mark T. Uyeda issued a joint statement dissenting from the agency’s action, arguing that the NFTs in question were utility tokens rather than securities. According to Peirce and Uyeda, the Flyfish NFTs were designed to provide access to exclusive dining experiences, not as speculative investment vehicles. They contended that the regulatory agency’s reliance on the Howey Test—an assessment used to determine what qualifies as a security—was overly broad in this case.

Hester Peirce and Mark T. Uyeda further argued that the non-fungible tokens offered tangible benefits and that the potential for resale profit should not automatically bring them under the purview of securities law. They raised concerns that the Securities and Exchange Commission intervention might negatively impact NFT holders by complicating the transfer and sale of their memberships.

The commissioners also suggested that the regulatory agency should provide clearer guidelines to allow creators and businesses to innovate with non-fungible tokens without fear of regulatory action. They emphasized that NFTs are a new tool for creators, such as chefs and artists, to monetize their talents and create unique experiences, which should not be stifled by overly rigid regulatory interpretations.

Advertisement

Increasing Scrutiny on NFT and Crypto Platforms

The US SEC’s action against Flyfish Club is part of a broader crackdown on non-fungible tokens and other digital asset platforms. Recently, OpenSea, an NFT marketplace, received a Wells Notice from the regulatory agency, indicating potential legal action over allegations that the digital collectibles traded on its platform could be considered securities.

This follows similar regulatory scrutiny faced by other crypto platforms, such as Coinbase, Kraken, and Uniswap. Subsequently, these actions have sparked criticism from various stakeholders, including lawmakers and industry experts, who argue that the regulatory agency’s approach under Chair Gary Gensler is overly aggressive.

Congressman William Timmons introduced the New Frontiers in Technology Act (NFT Act) to protect NFTs and these firms from the SEC’s crackdown. The bill specifies “the treatment of covered non-fungible tokens under the securities laws and for other purposes.” Covered NFTs basically refer to all non-fungible tokens except ones that are marketed as investment opportunities.

Meanwhile, an upcoming congressional hearing titled “Dazed and Confused: Breaking Down the SEC’s Politicized Approach to Digital Assets” will feature testimony from former regulatory agency officials and industry leaders, providing further insights into the agency’s regulatory direction and potential impact on the future of digital assets.

Advertisement

Share
Kelvin Munene Murithi

Kelvin Munene is a crypto and finance journalist with over 5 years of experience, offering in-depth market analysis and expert commentary . With a Bachelor's degree in Journalism and Actuarial Science from Mount Kenya University, Kelvin is known for his meticulous research and strong writing skills, particularly in cryptocurrency, blockchain, and financial markets. His work has been featured across top industry publications such as Coingape, Cryptobasic, MetaNews, Cryptotimes, Coinedition, TheCoinrepublic, Cryptotale, and Analytics Insight among others, where he consistently provides timely updates and insightful content. Kelvin’s focus lies in uncovering emerging trends in the crypto space, delivering factual and data-driven analyses that help readers make informed decisions. His expertise extends across market cycles, technological innovations, and regulatory shifts that shape the crypto landscape. Beyond his professional achievements, Kelvin has a passion for chess, traveling, and exploring new adventures.

Why trust CoinGape: CoinGape has covered the cryptocurrency industry since 2017, aiming to provide informative insights to our readers. Our journalists and analysts bring years of experience in market analysis and blockchain technology to ensure factual accuracy and balanced reporting. By following our Editorial Policy, our writers verify every source, fact-check each story, rely on reputable sources, and attribute quotes and media correctly. We also follow a rigorous Review Methodology when evaluating exchanges and tools. From emerging blockchain projects and coin launches to industry events and technical developments, we cover all facets of the digital asset space with unwavering commitment to timely, relevant information.
Investment disclaimer: The content reflects the author’s personal views and current market conditions. Please conduct your own research before investing in cryptocurrencies, as neither the author nor the publication is responsible for any financial losses.
Ad Disclosure: This site may feature sponsored content and affiliate links. All advertisements are clearly labeled, and ad partners have no influence over our editorial content.

Recent Posts

  • Bitcoin News

Breaking: Bitcoin Hits New ATH Above $125k as ‘Uptober’ Kicks Off in Full Force

The Bitcoin price has hit a new all-time high, after staging a monstrous rally since…

October 5, 2025
  • Bitcoin News

99.3% of Bitcoin Supply in Profit, Analyst Warns of Short-Term Correction

Bitcoin (BTC) is in profit on almost all of its supply, leading to discussion by…

October 5, 2025
  • 24/7 Cryptocurrency News

Pro-Crypto Mike Selig Emerges As CFTC Chair Frontrunner, Gains Ripple CLO’s Endorsement

Pro-crypto Mike Selig is reportedly the frontrunner to become the next chair of the U.S.…

October 4, 2025
  • 24/7 Cryptocurrency News

‘Every Crypto ETF You Can Imagine’: Expert Predicts Flurry of Filings After REX-Osprey’s 21 Applications

Nate Geraci, president of Novadius Wealth Management, has predicted that several crypto ETF filings could…

October 4, 2025
  • Bitcoin News

Robinhood Lists Strategy’s Bitcoin-Backed Stocks, Boosting Saylor’s BTC Credit Model

Bitcoin-backed stocks of Strategy can now be accessed on Robinhood. This represents a significant move…

October 4, 2025
  • Bitcoin News

Bitcoin ETFs See 2025 Record Weekly Inflows of $3.2B as BTC Eyes New ATH

The Bitcoin ETFs have seen a huge turnaround this week, recording their largest weekly inflows…

October 4, 2025