Why SEC Chair Gensler Is Wrong In Calling Ethereum A Security?
SEC chair Gary Gensler once again finds himself at the heart of a controversy. Gensler testified to the Senate Banking Committee regarding his stance on cryptocurrencies. During the hearing, Gensler revealed that the currencies using the Proof-of-stake model might be securities.
Ethereum, the second largest cryptocurrency, just underwent a merge that shifted its consensus mechanism to Proof-of-stake. Gensler recently called both Bitcoin and Ethereum a commodity and agreed that their enforcement should fall under the CFTC. However, in the recent hearing, he appears to have changed his stance again.
However, Jake Chervinsky, the head of policy at Blockchain Association, is correcting the record on the security vs. commodity debate for Ethereum.
Why Gensler Believes Ethereum Is A Security
Gary Gensler originally states that Bitcoin is the only cryptocurrency he is confident in calling a commodity. Recently, he included Ethereum into that criteria as well. However, it seems that he is reverting to his original stance after the merge.
Gensler’s testimony to the Senate Banking Committee reveals that cryptocurrencies dependent on the proof-of-stake mechanism can fall under the SEC. He believes that holders stake their currency in anticipation of profit, and therefore the cryptocurrency can be seen as an investment contract. If true, Ethereum can pass the Howey Test, which determines the assets that fall under Federal security law.
Since an Ethereum holder will make profits off the efforts of others, securities law will apply to Ethereum.
Why Gensler Is Incorrect In His Analysis
Jake Chervinsky of the Blockchain Association believes that Gensler’s analysis is incorrect. He highlights that people who understand securities law know that the merge does not make Ethereum appear more like a security.
Moreover, he also highlights that Ethereum is also a major derisking event, which is the exact opposite of Gensler’s views.
Senator Pat Toomey once again criticized SEC chair Gensler for not providing clarity on the security vs commodity debate.
- Polymarket Hits $20B in Trading Volume, Announces Plans for Massive POLY Token Airdrop
- James Wynn Takes XRP Long Bet After Ripple Prime Announcement
- Nasdaq-Listed Bonk Holdings Makes First Major Purchase of $32M, Nears 3% of Total Supply
- Binance-based Meme Coin GIGGLE Fund Shoots 145% on Exchange Listing News
- ASTER Gets Major Boost as Project Launches Token Buyback Program, Expert Predicts $10 Spike
- PEPE Coin Price Prediction as Weekly Outflows Hit $17M – Is Rebound Ahead?
- HBAR Price Targets 50% Jump as Hedera Unleashes Massive Staking Move
- Chainlink Price Outlook: Analyst Predicts $100 as Reserve Adds 63K LINK
- SUI Price Prediction as TVL and Monthly DEX Volume Hit All-Time Highs- What’s Next?
- PUMP Price Prediction as Whales Accumulate 4.2B Tokens- Is 135% Rally Next?
- Dogecoin Price Crash Looms as Flag, Death Cross, Falling DOGE ETF Inflows Coincide
Why Trust CoinGape
CoinGape has covered the cryptocurrency industry since 2017, aiming to provide informative insights Read more…to our readers. Our journal analysts bring years of experience in market analysis and blockchain technology to ensure factual accuracy and balanced reporting. By following our Editorial Policy, our writers verify every source, fact-check each story, rely on reputable sources, and attribute quotes and media correctly. We also follow a rigorous Review Methodology when evaluating exchanges and tools. From emerging blockchain projects and coin launches to industry events and technical developments, we cover all facets of the digital asset space with unwavering commitment to timely, relevant information.
