News

US SEC Commissioners Not Happy Over Impact Theory NFT Charges

US SEC NFT enforcement faces internal dissent; Commissioners question if NFTs equate to securities after Impact Theory's $30M sale.
Published by
US SEC Commissioners Not Happy Over Impact Theory NFT Charges

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) initiated enforcement action against non-fungible token (NFT) operations. However, this hasn’t sat well with all of its members. Notably, in a recent release, U.S. SEC`s Mark Uyeda and Hester Peirce voiced their dissent against the agency’s decision to enforce regulations on NFT sales classified as securities.

Advertisement

A Matter of Overreach or Protection?

The commission’s concerns were evident. Despite unclear prospects of use or profit, the enthusiasm with which people invested in the NFTs was alarming. However, the dissenting commissioners argued that the legitimate concerns don’t necessarily grant the US SEC jurisdiction. The promotional statements made by the company and its purchasers, they say, don’t align with promises typically seen in investment contracts.

For context, according to the commissioners, when artists or manufacturers market tangible goods such as watches or art, promoting the potential of the brand’s value isn’t usually grounds for SEC scrutiny. The commissioners emphasized this distinction, arguing that the NFT scenario presented a similar case.

Moreover, for registration violation cases, the usual remedy is an offer of rescission. Impact Theory had already proposed repurchase programs, compensating their purchasers to $7.7 million in Ether.

Advertisement

Controversy Around Impact Theory NFT

Impact Theory raised eyebrows with a $30 million NFT sale, boosting its offerings with bold claims that the value of these tokens would see a rise. Notably, a certain enthusiasm resonated amongst the purchasers. 

One was even allegedly quoted comparing their purchase to investing in major names like “Disney, Call of Duty, and YouTube.” However, unlike shares, these NFTs didn’t represent any ownership in the company or provide dividends to its holders. The SEC’s main contention was that Impact Theory projected the NFTs as investment contracts, leading to them operating an unregistered securities offering.

Advertisement

Share
Sunil Sharma

Sunil is a serial entrepreneur and has been working in blockchain and cryptocurrency space for 2 years now. Previously he co-founded Govt. of India supported startup InThinks and is currently Chief Editor at Coingape and CEO at SquadX, a fintech startup. He has published more than 100 articles on cryptocurrency and blockchain and has assisted a number of ICO's in their success. He has co-designed blockchain development industrial training and has hosted many interviews in past. Follow him on X at @sharmasunil8114 and reach out to him at sunil (at) coingape.com

Published by
Why trust CoinGape: CoinGape has covered the cryptocurrency industry since 2017, aiming to provide informative insights to our readers. Our journalists and analysts bring years of experience in market analysis and blockchain technology to ensure factual accuracy and balanced reporting. By following our Editorial Policy, our writers verify every source, fact-check each story, rely on reputable sources, and attribute quotes and media correctly. We also follow a rigorous Review Methodology when evaluating exchanges and tools. From emerging blockchain projects and coin launches to industry events and technical developments, we cover all facets of the digital asset space with unwavering commitment to timely, relevant information.
Investment disclaimer: The content reflects the author’s personal views and current market conditions. Please conduct your own research before investing in cryptocurrencies, as neither the author nor the publication is responsible for any financial losses.
Ad Disclosure: This site may feature sponsored content and affiliate links. All advertisements are clearly labeled, and ad partners have no influence over our editorial content.

Recent Posts

  • News

Senators Reaffirm Commitment to Market Structure Bill After Meeting with Coinbase, Ripple

Senate Democrats and Republican lawmakers have ended separate roundtable meetings focused on the Crypto Market…

October 23, 2025
  • News

How the Crypto Market Could React to the Next Fed Meeting on October 29?

The crypto market has, for a while now, been pricing a potential 25 basis points…

October 23, 2025
  • News

$1.68 Trillion T. Rowe Price Files for First Active Crypto ETF Holding BTC, ETH, SOL, and XRP

Rowe Price has filed for its first actively managed crypto exchange-traded fund (ETF). It is…

October 22, 2025
  • News

Standard Chartered Predicts Bitcoin Could Drop Below $100K Amid U.S.–China Trade Tensions

Standard Chartered analyst Geoff Kendrick has predicted that the Bitcoin price could suffer a significant…

October 22, 2025
  • News

Rising Demand for Verifiable Crypto Ownership Drives Launch of Trezor Safe 7

Crypto ownership is a topic that has been discussed across major forums globally in the…

October 22, 2025
  • News

Robinhood Lists Binance Coin as BNB Outperforms BTC, ETH, SOL YTD By Over 30%

Crypto exchange Robinhood has listed the Binance coin for spot trading for its U.S. customers.…

October 22, 2025