Ripple Headed For Victory? Stuart Alderoty Predicts SEC Appeal Outcome

Stuart Alderoty, the Chief Legal Officer (CLO) of Ripple, recently provided an insightful perspective on the ongoing legal battle between Ripple and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). As the case progresses, Alderoty suggests that the possibilities range from a full affirmation of Judge Torres’s decision by the Second Circuit to a potential expansion of her rulings. 

A less likely outcome, according to Alderoty, could see the case remanded back to Judge Torres for further deliberation.

Ripple CLO Stuart Alderoty Shares Major Insight Ahead of SEC Appeal

In a recent post on X platform, Alderoty suggested that the Second Circuit, might either affirm the decision by Judge Analisa Torres or possibly expand on her ruling. Further, Ripple CLO expressed confidence in the XRP company’s position, noting that the best outcome the SEC could hope for would be a remand to the lower court. 

Stuart Alderoty highlighted the improbability of the appeal succeeding in overturning Judge Torres’s original decisions, suggesting that the best the SEC could hope for would be a remand.

Such a scenario would reopen Ripple’s original defenses, including the “Fair Notice” defense. This defense questions whether a party of ordinary intelligence would have known that their actions were against the law.  Alderoty said,

“ The SEC could end up arguing to Judge Torres that she wasn’t a person of ‘ordinary intelligence’ when she ruled against them. Awkward.”

Additionally, the Ripple CLO drew an analogy between the SEC’s persistent legal pursuit and the literary work “Moby Dick,” with SEC Chair Gary Gensler cast in the role of Captain Ahab. More so, Stuart Alderoty humorously added that the situation now mirrors comedic elements similar to the movie “My Cousin Vinny.” This light-hearted comparison underscores the perceived overreach and determination of the SEC in its regulatory enforcement against Ripple.

Previous Rulings and Community Reactions

In the earlier stages of the litigation, the court ruled in favor of Ripple, rejecting the Securities and Exchange Commission’s arguments regarding XRP status as a security. Most recently, Alderoty shared updates with the XRP community, reassuring them that the verdict that “XRP is not a security” remains unchallenged. This clarification boosted community sentiment, with expectations of a potential rebound in XRP price.

In addition to Stuart Alderoty views, legal analysts like James Murphy and Fred Rispoli, along with former Securities and Exchange Commission lawyer Marc Fagel, have commented on the proceedings. They highlighted that while the SEC opted not to appeal the decision on disgorgement during the remedies phase, the final judgment remains open for argument in the appellate briefs. 

However, despite the Ripple vs SEC legal challenges, the impending launch of its RLUSD stablecoin could elevate XRP price towards $2 milestone.

At press time, XRP price is $0.54, marking a 3.5% increase over the past week. The cryptocurrency’s market cap stands at $30 billion, with a 24-hour trading volume of $622 million.