SEC Hit with Privacy Lawsuit Over Trading Data Collection

Kelvin Munene Murithi
April 17, 2024
Why Trust CoinGape
CoinGape has covered the cryptocurrency industry since 2017, aiming to provide informative insights to our readers. Our journal analysts bring years of experience in market analysis and blockchain technology to ensure factual accuracy and balanced reporting. By following our Editorial Policy, our writers verify every source, fact-check each story, rely on reputable sources, and attribute quotes and media correctly. We also follow a rigorous Review Methodology when evaluating exchanges and tools. From emerging blockchain projects and coin launches to industry events and technical developments, we cover all facets of the digital asset space with unwavering commitment to timely, relevant information.
SEC's Mute Stance on Ether Classification was Misleading, Says Patrick McHenry

Highlights

  • NCLA files lawsuit claiming SEC's CAT violates First, Fourth, Fifth Amendments.
  • CAT is criticized for potential massive cybersecurity risks and privacy violations.
  • The lawsuit challenges the SEC's authority to create CAT without Congressional approval.

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) was sued on April 16, 2024, over the implementation of the Consolidated Audit Trail (CAT), a system designed to gather complete trading data from U.S. exchanges.

This lawsuit has been filed by the New Civil Liberties Alliance (NCLA) on behalf of investors and the National Center for Public Policy Research to challenge the constitutionality of CAT, claiming violations of several constitutional amendments and federal statutes.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Disadvantages of the CAT System

The plaintiffs argue that the SEC has overstepped its regulatory authority by establishing the CAT without particular consent from Congress. This database, intended to keep a record of all the equity and options transactions in the United States, is accused of infringing the privacy rights because of the necessity to store huge volumes of personal financial data for a long time.

The complaint argues that such actions do not comply with the First, Fourth, and Fifth Amendments, ensuring freedom of speech, protection from unreasonable searches and seizures, and due process, respectively.

The complaint also claims that the SEC’s actions violate the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), which is the principle regulating the process of creating and issuing regulations by federal agencies. In addition, the CAT is considered to pose a major risk to data security, which could lead to the exposure of confidential financial data to cyber threats.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Financial and Regulatory Implications

The critics of CAT, including Hester Peirce, the SEC Commissioner, equate this system to unwarranted government surveillance, offering examples where a government could use GPS to track all consumer purchases or movements without any oversight or probable cause.

Moreover, the system tends to be seen as a violation of privacy and an illegal power in that the SEC imposes financial obligations to the regulated broker-dealers and self-regulatory organizations in funding the CAT. This litigation also highlights the possible economic consequences of the surveillance system, which will spoil investors’ trust and discourage individual and institutional participation in U.S. financial markets because of privacy issues.

Advertisement
Advertisement

SEC’s Response

In a statement regarding the filing, a representative of the SEC defended the power of the agency and the importance of the CAT in enhancing the ability of the regulator to track market activities effectively. The CAT, as stipulated by the SEC, is called to occupy an essential gap in the regulatory regime by making more efficient the tracking of market transactions that, prior to this, would have been inefficient and cumbersome.

The outcome of this lawsuit, Davidson v. Gensler, could have significant implications for how regulatory bodies collect and use personal data in the future and may set a precedent for the limits of governmental data collection practices in the financial sector. The case is currently pending in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas.

Read Also: Senate’s Sherrod Brown Unexpectedly Backs Push for Stablecoin Law

Advertisement
coingape google news coingape google news
Investment disclaimer: The content reflects the author’s personal views and current market conditions. Please conduct your own research before investing in cryptocurrencies, as neither the author nor the publication is responsible for any financial losses.
Ad Disclosure: This site may feature sponsored content and affiliate links. All advertisements are clearly labeled, and ad partners have no influence over our editorial content.

Why Trust CoinGape

CoinGape has covered the cryptocurrency industry since 2017, aiming to provide informative insights Read more…to our readers. Our journal analysts bring years of experience in market analysis and blockchain technology to ensure factual accuracy and balanced reporting. By following our Editorial Policy, our writers verify every source, fact-check each story, rely on reputable sources, and attribute quotes and media correctly. We also follow a rigorous Review Methodology when evaluating exchanges and tools. From emerging blockchain projects and coin launches to industry events and technical developments, we cover all facets of the digital asset space with unwavering commitment to timely, relevant information.

About Author
About Author
Kelvin Munene is a crypto and finance journalist with over 5 years of experience, offering in-depth market analysis and expert commentary . With a Bachelor's degree in Journalism and Actuarial Science from Mount Kenya University, Kelvin is known for his meticulous research and strong writing skills, particularly in cryptocurrency, blockchain, and financial markets. His work has been featured across top industry publications such as Coingape, Cryptobasic, MetaNews, Cryptotimes, Coinedition, TheCoinrepublic, Cryptotale, and Analytics Insight among others, where he consistently provides timely updates and insightful content. Kelvin’s focus lies in uncovering emerging trends in the crypto space, delivering factual and data-driven analyses that help readers make informed decisions. His expertise extends across market cycles, technological innovations, and regulatory shifts that shape the crypto landscape. Beyond his professional achievements, Kelvin has a passion for chess, traveling, and exploring new adventures.
Investment disclaimer: The content reflects the author’s personal views and current market conditions. Please conduct your own research before investing in cryptocurrencies, as neither the author nor the publication is responsible for any financial losses.
Ad Disclosure: This site may feature sponsored content and affiliate links. All advertisements are clearly labeled, and ad partners have no influence over our editorial content.